What Happens If You Miss a Chapter 13 Plan Payment

What Happens If You Miss a Chapter 13 Plan Payment

Short answer: A missed Chapter 13 plan payment does not end your case. The trustee normally issues a notice of default first, and dismissal requires a motion plus notice and a hearing. Four remedies are available: cure the arrears, modify the plan under § 1329, convert to Chapter 7 under § 1307(a), or seek a hardship discharge under § 1328(b).

One missed payment does not end your Chapter 13 case.

If you are reading this a few days after a shortfall, take a breath. Plans are funded by paychecks, and paychecks are not always predictable. Trustees know this. Judges know this. The Bankruptcy Code itself contains several tools built for exactly this moment, which tells you something: Congress expected life to happen in the middle of a five year plan.

What matters now is not the size of the shortfall. What matters is how quickly you and your attorney respond. You have at least four named remedies available, and every one of them works better when raised early. Below is what actually happens after a missed payment, what each remedy does, and what a dismissal would genuinely cost you.

What Actually Happens First

The first thing to understand is that nobody flips a switch. A missed payment does not automatically close your case.

The trustee sees it on the ledger

Your Chapter 13 trustee keeps a running account of every payment received and every distribution made. A shortfall shows up there within a payment cycle or two. The trustee’s first move is typically administrative rather than adversarial: a notice of default, a delinquency letter, or a request that your attorney explain the gap.

A motion to dismiss is a filing, not a verdict

If the shortfall goes unaddressed, the trustee may file a motion to dismiss. Under 11 U.S.C. § 1307(c)(6), a material default on a term of a confirmed plan is cause for the court to dismiss the case or convert it. Note the operative words. The court may act, and only after notice and a hearing. That interval between the filing and the hearing is your working window, and it is usually measured in weeks rather than days.

Your mortgage lender may file separately

If you have also fallen behind on the ongoing mortgage payments you make outside the plan, your lender may file its own motion for relief from the automatic stay. This runs on a separate track from the trustee’s motion and needs its own response. Many of these motions are resolved by a conditional order rather than by outright stay relief.

Remedy One: Cure the Arrears

The simplest remedy is also the most common. Catch up.

If the shortfall came from a one time event such as a car repair, a brief layoff, or a delayed commission check, and your income has since recovered, paying the missed amount may fully resolve the issue. A lump sum works. So does a short catch up period layered on top of your regular plan payment.

Where a lump sum is not realistic, trustees will frequently agree to a conditional order, sometimes called a stipulation. The structure is straightforward. The motion to dismiss is held in abeyance, you commit to a specific catch up schedule, and the case continues as long as you meet it. Practice varies by district and by trustee, so your attorney’s familiarity with the local trustee matters.

Here is the part most articles get wrong. Speed matters more than the size of the shortfall. Someone four payments behind who calls the day the notice arrives is often in better shape than someone one payment behind who waits three months. Early contact preserves the full menu of remedies. Late contact narrows it to whatever remains after the court has set a hearing date.

Remedy Two: Modify the Plan

If your income has changed in a lasting way, curing the arrears solves the wrong problem. You do not need to catch up to a payment you can no longer afford. You need a different payment.

Section 1329 of the Bankruptcy Code exists for this. At any time after confirmation but before you complete your payments, the plan may be modified at the request of the debtor, the trustee, or the holder of an allowed unsecured claim. A modification can:

  • Increase or reduce the amount of payments on claims of a particular class
  • Extend or reduce the time for those payments
  • Adjust a creditor’s distribution to account for payments made outside the plan
  • Reduce plan payments by the documented cost of health insurance you purchased, subject to the statute’s reasonableness conditions

For someone who has missed payments, the practical move is usually a combination of the first two: roll the missed amount into the remaining term and lower the going forward payment to match current income. A modification is a request to the court, and it succeeds on evidence, which is why documenting the income change matters so much.

The sixty month outer limit

There is one hard ceiling. Under § 1329(c), a modified plan cannot provide for payments over a period expiring after the applicable commitment period, and the court may not approve a period expiring more than five years after the time the first payment under the original confirmed plan was due.

Read that measuring point carefully, because it is commonly misstated. The five years runs from when your first payment under the original confirmed plan came due. It does not run from the date you file the modification. Someone in month 14 of a plan has meaningfully more room to stretch payments than someone in month 50, and that difference alone often decides which remedy is realistic.

Remedy Three: Convert to Chapter 7

Sometimes the honest answer is that the plan no longer fits the life.

Section 1307(a) is unusually direct. A Chapter 13 debtor may convert the case to Chapter 7 at any time, and any waiver of that right is unenforceable. It is one of the few genuinely unilateral rights in the Code. The practical limit sits in § 1307(g): you must actually be eligible to be a debtor under the new chapter, so the means test and prior discharge timing still apply to a Chapter 7 filing.

Conversion makes sense when a discharge without a plan is the better outcome. If a job loss turned out to be permanent rather than temporary, or if the asset you filed to protect is no longer affordable even at a reduced payment, continuing to fund a plan can mean paying for years toward a finish line you will not reach.

What happens to secured debt

Be clear eyed here. Chapter 7 has no mechanism to cure arrears over time. That cure mechanism is the entire reason a Chapter 13 repayment plan saves houses. After conversion your mortgage arrears remain, and once the stay lifts or the case closes, the lender may resume foreclosure. You may still be able to keep the property by becoming current, by reaffirming, or by negotiating directly with the servicer, but the structured catch up is gone.

Conversion is the right answer for some people. It is rarely the right answer for someone whose main goal is still keeping the house.

Remedy Four: Hardship Discharge

There is a fourth path far fewer filers know about.

Under 11 U.S.C. § 1328(b), the court may grant a discharge to a debtor who has not completed plan payments. All three statutory conditions must be met:

  1. The failure to complete payments is due to circumstances for which you should not justly be held accountable
  2. Unsecured creditors have already received at least what they would have received in a Chapter 7 liquidation, valued as of the effective date of the plan
  3. Modification of the plan under § 1329 is not practicable

The first condition is the one people ask about. The statutory language points toward external causes rather than choices: a disabling illness, a plant closing, the death of a household member who was contributing income. The third condition matters just as much. A hardship discharge is a last resort by design. If your plan can be modified, the court will expect you to modify it instead.

How the scope differs

A hardship discharge is narrower than the discharge you receive for completing a plan. Section 1328(c) excludes debts provided for under § 1322(b)(5), which covers long term obligations such as your mortgage, and it excludes every category listed in § 523(a). A completed plan discharge under § 1328(a) reaches further.

In plain terms: a hardship discharge can end the case and clear qualifying unsecured debt, but it does not erase mortgage arrears.

What Dismissal Would Actually Cost

It is worth being precise about the downside.

The automatic stay ends. This is the real cost. The protection that stopped the sheriff’s sale, the repossession, and the wage garnishment stops with it, and foreclosure or repossession may resume under Pennsylvania law.

Your payments are credited, not refunded. Money the trustee already distributed to creditors is applied against those debts. Funds still held by the trustee at dismissal are generally returned to you, though the handling depends on the posture of your case. What you lose is the protection, not the credit.

Liens come back. Dismissal generally reinstates avoided liens and revests estate property in whoever held it before you filed, which can undo lien avoidance work already completed in the case.

Refiling is not a reset button

This is the most important paragraph here for anyone thinking about letting a case go and simply filing again.

Under 11 U.S.C. § 362(c)(3), if you had a case pending within the preceding one year period that was dismissed, the automatic stay in your new case terminates on the thirtieth day after filing. Extending it requires a motion, with notice and a hearing completed before that thirty day window closes, plus a showing that the later case was filed in good faith. If two or more of your cases were dismissed in the previous year, § 362(c)(4) provides that no stay goes into effect at all unless the court orders one.

A dismissed case followed by a refiling buys you thirty days of protection and a contested motion, not the clean slate you had the first time.

How to Protect Your Case This Month

If you have missed a payment or you can see one coming, three actions this month protect nearly every option above.

Tell your attorney before the trustee tells you. This is the highest value thing you can do and it costs nothing. A shortfall your attorney hears about from you is a planning problem. A shortfall your attorney hears about from a motion to dismiss is a litigation problem running on someone else’s schedule.

Document the reason. A termination letter, a reduction in hours notice, a disability determination, hospital discharge paperwork, a death certificate for a household contributor. Both a plan modification and a hardship discharge turn on why the shortfall happened, and that reason has to be shown rather than described.

Gather current income records. Recent pay stubs, or a year to date profit and loss statement if you are self employed. A modification cannot be drafted around income nobody can verify, and having these ready is often the difference between filing in days and filing in weeks.

If you can make partial payments while this gets sorted out, make them. Continued good faith payment is visible on the ledger and it matters.

Talk to Us Before Your Case Is Dismissed

If you have missed a Chapter 13 payment or you know one is coming, a call today usually preserves every option described above. Waiting for the dismissal notice removes most of them.

Attorney John M. Hyams has practiced bankruptcy law exclusively for more than twenty years, guiding Central Pennsylvania families through job losses, illnesses, and income swings without losing the homes and vehicles their plans were built to protect. Recognized with Harrisburg Magazine’s Simply the Best award in 2020, 2024, and 2025, the firm maintains seven Central Pennsylvania offices. Consultations are free and available in person, by phone, or online.

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Or call directly: 717.520.0300

If you are planning ahead rather than reacting, our guide to saving your home from foreclosure through Chapter 13 explains how plans are structured from the start, and our bankruptcy calculator offers a preliminary look at how a plan payment is built.

Legal Disclaimer. This information is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Results may vary based on individual circumstances. Bankruptcy law is complex and the general principles described here may not apply to your specific case. For guidance on your own Chapter 13 case, please consult a qualified bankruptcy attorney. The Law Offices of John M. Hyams is a debt relief agency helping people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. Attorney advertising, compliant with Pennsylvania Bar rules.

Frequently Asked Questions

Back to all articles