Choosing a Bankruptcy Attorney in Central Pennsylvania: Twelve Questions to Ask

Choosing a Bankruptcy Attorney in Central Pennsylvania: Twelve Questions to Ask

The best way to choose a bankruptcy attorney is to interview more than one, using the same questions at each consultation: how much of the practice is bankruptcy, who will actually handle your case, what strategy fits your situation, what the full cost is, and what support continues after filing. The twelve questions below work at any firm, including ours.

If you are comparing two or three law offices right now, you may feel unqualified to judge. Most people have never hired a bankruptcy lawyer before, and after a while the websites start to sound alike. That feeling is normal, and it does not mean you lack good judgment. It only means no one has handed you the right criteria yet.

A free consultation is not only a chance for an attorney to evaluate your case. It is your chance to evaluate the attorney. Print or save this list, bring it with you, and take notes. Afterward, compare the answers side by side. Clear, specific answers are a good sign. Vague ones are worth noticing.

Questions About Focus and Experience

Bankruptcy is a distinct area of federal law, with its own code, its own court, and its own local procedures. Experience inside that system tells you more than general legal experience does.

1. What share of your practice is bankruptcy, and for how long?

Some attorneys handle bankruptcy alongside divorce, wills, injury claims, and traffic cases. Others practice bankruptcy only. Neither answer automatically rules a lawyer in or out, but an attorney who works in this one area every day is more likely to know the current exemption rules, the means test, and the official forms thoroughly. Ask how many years they have practiced bankruptcy specifically, not law in general. For reference, John M. Hyams has practiced bankruptcy law exclusively for more than 20 years, which you can read about on his attorney profile.

2. How often do you appear before the trustees who will handle my case?

Every Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 case is assigned a private trustee, appointed by the U.S. Trustee Program, who reviews your paperwork. Central Pennsylvania cases are filed in either the Middle District or the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, depending on where you live, and each district has its own trustees, judges, and local rules. An attorney who regularly appears before those trustees tends to know which documents they expect and which questions they commonly ask. Ask which district your case would be filed in and how familiar the attorney is with its trustees.

3. Have you handled cases like mine?

Your situation has its own shape. Perhaps you own a home with equity, signed a personal guarantee for a business, are going through a divorce, are carrying medical bills, or have a car loan you want to keep. Ask whether the attorney has handled that kind of case and which issues usually come up. A good answer is specific without promising a result.

Listen for whether the attorney asks follow-up questions about your facts before answering. An experienced bankruptcy lawyer will often spot an issue you did not think to mention, such as a recent transfer to a relative, a tax refund on the way, or a lawsuit that is close to judgment.

Questions About Who Does the Work

Many firms rely on paralegals and staff to gather documents and prepare forms, and that can work well. What matters is knowing, before you sign anything, who is responsible for your case and who you will actually talk to.

4. Will you personally handle my case, and who attends the meeting of creditors with me?

Ask who will review your documents, give you legal advice, and sign your petition. Then ask who will sit beside you at the meeting of creditors, often called the 341 meeting. That meeting is a required step. It is conducted by the trustee rather than a judge, almost all are now held by video, and you answer questions under oath about your paperwork. The U.S. Trustee Program’s overview of the meeting of creditors describes what to expect. Whether your own attorney or a lawyer you have never met will appear with you is a fair thing to know in advance.

5. Who do I call when something goes wrong at nine at night?

Problems rarely arrive on schedule. A creditor may call after filing, a garnishment may show up on a paycheck, or a letter may arrive that you do not understand. Ask how you reach the firm, how quickly calls and messages are usually returned, and who your main point of contact will be. You are not asking for a promise of round-the-clock service. You are asking whether there is a real person and a real process behind the phone number, so a small problem does not sit unanswered over a weekend.

It also helps to ask how documents are exchanged and how you will be kept informed. Some people prefer a phone call, others prefer secure uploads and email. A firm with a clear routine for both tends to make the whole process feel lighter.

Questions About Strategy

This is where the consultation becomes about you. Strategy questions show whether the attorney has listened to your facts or is giving everyone the same answer.

6. Which chapter do you recommend, and why?

A careful attorney explains the reasoning, not just the conclusion. Chapter 7 generally eliminates qualifying unsecured debt within a few months, but eligibility depends on the means test and on whether any property would be at risk. Chapter 13 uses a three to five year repayment plan and can help people catch up on a mortgage or protect property that would not be safe in Chapter 7. Sometimes the honest answer is that bankruptcy is not the right tool at all. Ask the attorney to walk you through the tradeoffs in plain terms.

7. Which exemption system will you use, and what am I at risk of losing?

Exemptions are the laws that let you keep property. Pennsylvania filers generally choose between the federal exemption set and the Pennsylvania state exemptions, and the better choice depends on what you own. Our guide to Pennsylvania bankruptcy exemptions compares the two. Ask the attorney which system they would use for you, why, and what, specifically, would not be protected. A clear answer about risk is worth far more than general reassurance.

8. What tools apply to my liens, my car, or my home?

Bankruptcy law includes specific tools for secured debts. Depending on the facts, a judgment lien that impairs an exemption may be removable, a car loan may be reaffirmed or the car redeemed, and in Chapter 13 some vehicle loans taken out more than 910 days before filing may be restructured around the car’s value. Missed mortgage payments can often be caught up through a Chapter 13 plan. You do not need to know these terms in advance. You only need to ask which tools apply to you and listen for a specific, practical answer.

A strong strategy answer also covers timing. Ask whether anything in your situation, such as a recent large payment to a creditor or an upcoming change in income, affects when you should file.

Try These Questions on Us

Bring this list to a free consultation and ask anything on it. You are welcome to compare our answers with any other firm’s before you decide.

Questions About Cost

Talking about money with a lawyer can feel awkward, especially when money is the problem. It should not be. Federal law requires bankruptcy attorneys to put their services and fees in writing, and a good firm welcomes cost questions.

9. What is the total fee, what does it include, and are payment arrangements available?

Ask for the total attorney fee for your case and a plain list of what it covers: document review, preparation of the petition and schedules, the meeting of creditors, and routine follow-up with the trustee. Under federal law, a bankruptcy attorney must give you a written contract that clearly explains the services, the fees, and the terms of payment within five business days after first providing services, and before your case is filed. Your attorney must also disclose the fee to the court. Ask whether payment arrangements are available. In Chapter 13, part of the attorney fee can often be paid through the plan itself.

10. What is not included, and how are court and course fees handled?

Ask what would cost extra, such as responding to a creditor’s objection, handling a lawsuit filed inside the bankruptcy, or amending your papers after filing. Then ask how the court filing fee is handled. The court can allow the filing fee to be paid in installments, and in some Chapter 7 cases it can be waived for people with lower incomes. You will also complete two required courses, one before filing and one after, and approved providers must offer them free or at a reduced rate based on your ability to pay. A firm that explains all of this up front is showing you how it will communicate for the rest of your case.

Before you leave, it is reasonable to ask for the fee terms in writing so you can compare firms at home without pressure.

Questions About After the Filing

Filing is not the finish line. The months after filing, and even the period after discharge, are when a responsive attorney matters most.

11. What happens if a creditor keeps calling after discharge, and is post-filing support included?

A discharge works as a court order that prohibits creditors from trying to collect discharged debts from you personally. Most creditors comply. When one does not, your attorney can contact the creditor, and if needed the case can be reopened so the court can address the problem. Ask whether that follow-up is part of the fee. Also ask what support is included between filing and discharge, such as trustee document requests, questions about your car or house, and letters that arrive after filing. Many issues are simple to resolve when someone reviews them the same week they arrive.

12. Will you help with credit report corrections?

After discharge, your credit reports should show discharged accounts as included in bankruptcy with no balance owed, but errors do happen. You can dispute an inaccurate item with the credit reporting company online, by mail, or by phone, and the company must investigate. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains how to dispute a credit report error, including what to send. Ask whether the firm will provide your discharge order and creditor list for disputes, and whether it helps when an error is not corrected.

Finally, ask what the attorney recommends for rebuilding afterward. A thoughtful answer might cover keeping a simple budget, using credit carefully, and checking your reports periodically. Life after bankruptcy is the reason you are filing, and a good attorney treats it as part of the plan rather than an afterthought. The goal is not only to end the debt, but to help you move forward with confidence.

Warning Signs Worth Noticing

Most bankruptcy attorneys are conscientious professionals. Still, a few patterns are worth noticing, because they suggest your case may not get the attention it deserves.

A quote before anyone reviewed your situation

A firm may reasonably share a general fee range on the phone. But a firm that announces a final price and a chapter before asking about your income, property, debts, and goals has not learned enough yet to give you a real answer. The right fee and the right chapter both depend on what your case requires.

Pressure to sign at the first meeting

You are allowed to go home, think, and compare. Unless a sheriff’s sale, repossession, or court date is days away, there is usually time to decide. Urgency should come from your actual deadlines, not from a sales script. An attorney who respects your decision at the consultation is likely to respect it throughout the case.

Vague answers about exemptions and property

If you ask what you could lose and hear only that everyone keeps everything, ask again. Many people do keep all of their property, but every case depends on its facts. A careful attorney names the assets that are protected, the ones that need attention, and why.

No clear point of contact

If no one can tell you who will answer your questions after you sign, that uncertainty usually grows over time. Before you hire anyone, you can also confirm a Pennsylvania attorney’s contact information and public disciplinary history through the Disciplinary Board’s attorney lookup.

One warning sign does not mean you should walk away. It means you should ask a follow-up question and see how the attorney responds. A firm that answers patiently and specifically, even when the question is uncomfortable, is usually a firm that will handle the rest of your case the same way. Trust what you observe in that first conversation.

What a Good Consultation Feels Like

Beyond the answers themselves, notice how the conversation feels. You should leave with more clarity than you brought in.

Questions about your goals before recommendations

A good consultation starts with listening. What worries you most? What do you want to keep? What would a fresh start look like for you? Recommendations should come after those questions, not before them.

Plain language rather than jargon

Terms like automatic stay, means test, and reaffirmation should come with an explanation you could repeat to a spouse or a family member. If you leave confused, that is a reason to ask more questions, not a reflection on you.

Honest limits on what bankruptcy can do

Bankruptcy is a powerful legal tool, but it has limits. Domestic support obligations, many tax debts, and in most cases student loans are generally not discharged, and some property may need a plan to protect it. An attorney who tells you what bankruptcy cannot do is easier to trust about what it can do.

No judgment about how you got here

Job loss, illness, divorce, and a business that did not survive are among the most common reasons people file. You deserve respect from the first phone call. Feeling comfortable being completely honest with your attorney is not a luxury. It is how your case gets prepared correctly.

If a consultation leaves you feeling heard, informed, and free to decide, you have probably found an attorney worth considering seriously. That feeling matters a great deal.

Bring These Questions to a Free Consultation

Interview Us With This List

Bring this list to any consultation, including ours. Attorney John M. Hyams has practiced bankruptcy law exclusively for more than 20 years, and the firm has been recognized with Harrisburg Magazine’s Simply the Best award in 2020, 2024, and 2025. Clients from all walks of life, including teachers, doctors, business owners, and blue-collar workers, have sat across the table from us with these same worries. Meet in person at one of seven Central Pennsylvania offices in Harrisburg, Mechanicsburg, Hershey, York, Lancaster, East Petersburg, and Lititz, or meet online or by phone. Ask every question on this page. We will answer each one plainly, tell you what bankruptcy can and cannot do for you, and leave the decision with you. There is no cost and no obligation to hire us. Call 717.520.0300 or book online at a time that works for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Legal Disclaimer
This information is provided for educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every financial situation is unique, and results may vary based on individual circumstances. The questions and descriptions in this article reflect federal bankruptcy law and general practice; fees, procedures, and the treatment of any particular debt or property depend on the facts of your case, the trustee, and the court, and no outcome can be promised in advance. Local procedures in the Middle and Eastern Districts of Pennsylvania may differ. For personalized guidance, please consult a qualified bankruptcy attorney. The Law Offices of John M. Hyams is a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes.
Back to all articles